The Greatest SF Movie Of All Time
In conjunction with the debut of Adam P. Knave’s Crazy Little Things at the 51st Annual Lunacon in New York, DMD! surveyed con-goers for what they considered to be the Greatest Science Fiction Movie of All Time. We began with a ballot listing five titles designed to foment controversy: Metropolis, Plan 9 From Outer Space, Star Wars, Alien, and Independence Day, along with a space for a write-in nomination. The votes were tallied and the results are as follows:
- Plan 9 From Outer Space, despite having the requisite spaceships, aliens, and other science fictiony stuff, came in last with only 5 votes.
- Independence Day, which has aliens, spaceships, and Will Smith, garnered only 7 votes.
- Metropolis, Fritz Lang’s silent spectacular, came in third, with 12 votes.
- Alien, Ridley Scott’s big-budget remake of IT! The Terror From Beyond Space, racked up a decent 20 votes.
- And, topping them all, and reigning supreme at the top of the heap, was Star Wars (retroactively known as Star Wars Episode 4: A New Hope–and my girlfriend tells me that it is sad that I know this), with a stunning 42 votes. This, despite all efforts from various DMD staffers to rig the vote in favor of Ed Wood’s clearly superior and infinitely more heartfelt anti-classic.
The write-in votes are also worth noting:
- The 13th Warrior (1)
- 2001: A Space Odyssey (5)
- Aliens (1)
- Barbarella (1)
- Bladerunner (12)
- The Birds (1)
- Brazil (1)
- Children Of Men (1)
- Close Encounters of the Third Kind (2)
- Cloverfield (1)
- The Day The Earth Stood Still (7)
- Demolition Man (1)
- The Empire Strikes Back (2)
- Equilibrium (1)
- Fantastic Voyage (1)
- The Fly ‘86 (1)
- Forbidden Planet (6)
- Gattaca (1)
- Godzilla ‘54 (1)
- Howard The Duck (1)
- Just Imagine (1)
- Killer Klowns From Outer Space (1)
- Logan’s Run (1)
- Pitch Black (1)
- Planet Of The Apes ‘69 (2)
- Royal Space Force (1)
- Santa Claus Conquers The Martians (1)
- Serenity (8)
- Solaris ‘72 (1)
- Things To Come (1)
- The Time Machine ‘60 (1)
- Tron (1)
…and, finally, the oddest write-in vote:
- Singing In The Rain (1)

